Top Local Dishes & Where to Try Them in Brookhaven, New York, United States
1. Clam Pie from Tick Hall's Bakery
Savor a local favorite, the Clam Pie, at Tick Hall's Bakery, known for its rich clam filling and flaky crust.
- Authentic Experience: Offers a taste of traditional Brookhaven cuisine
- Unique Recipe: Features a secret family recipe passed down for generations
- Cozy Atmosphere: Bakery's warm and inviting ambiance adds to the dining experience
2. Brookhaven Burger from The Speakeasy
Experience the mouthwatering Brookhaven Burger at The Speakeasy, crafted with local beef and house-made ingredients.
- Local Sourcing: Uses locally sourced, high-quality ingredients
- Creative Flair: Offers a unique twist on the classic burger
- Hip Atmosphere: Vibrant speakeasy-style decor adds to the dining experience
3. Farmstand Eggs Benedict from Green Thumb Farm
Savor freshness at its best with the Farmstand Eggs Benedict at Green Thumb Farm, made with farm-fresh ingredients.
- Farm-to-Table: Dishes are prepared using ingredients grown on site
- Seasonal Menu: Menu changes with the availability of seasonal produce
- Rustic Charm: Restaurant's rustic, farmhouse atmosphere adds to the dining experience
4. Lobster Roll from The BoatHouse
Enjoy a classic Lobster Roll at The BoatHouse, where the freshness of the lobster truly shines.
- Seafood Specialty: Known for its exceptional seafood offerings
- Waterfront Views: Offers stunning views of the marina and bay
- Seasonal Ingredients: Uses fresh, seasonally available lobster
5. Smoked Fish Platter from The Clam Bar
Indulge in a Smoked Fish Platter at The Clam Bar, featuring a selection of smoked fish and house-made condiments.
- Fresh Catch: Offers a daily selection of freshly caught seafood
- Local Favorite: A beloved staple in the Brookhaven culinary scene
- Coastal Ambiance: Restaurant's coastal decor and waterfront views add to the dining experience
6. Pizza Margherita from Vito's Pizzeria
Experience authentic Italian cuisine at Vito's Pizzeria with their classic Pizza Margherita.
- Authentic Italian Cuisine: Prepared using traditional Italian methods
- Fresh Ingredients: Made with fresh, high-quality ingredients
- Family-Friendly Atmosphere: A welcoming environment for both families and couples
7. Crab Cakes from The Halyard
Treat yourself to the succulent Crab Cakes at The Halyard, made with fresh, lump crab meat.
- Seafood Specialty: Known for its exceptional seafood offerings
- Waterfront Views: Offers stunning views of the marina and bay
- Fresh Ingredients: Uses fresh, high-quality ingredients
8. Lamb Gyro from The Greek Deli
Savor the flavors of Greece with a delicious Lamb Gyro at The Greek Deli.
- Authentic Greek Cuisine: Prepared using traditional Greek recipes
- Quick Service: Offers quick, convenient service for busy travelers
- Affordable Prices: Provides affordable options for budget-conscious travelers
9. Brookhaven Breakfast Sandwich from The Local Eatery
Start your day off right with the Brookhaven Breakfast Sandwich at The Local Eatery.
- Local Favorite: A beloved staple in the Brookhaven breakfast scene
- Fresh Ingredients: Made with fresh, high-quality ingredients
- Friendly Service: Known for its friendly and welcoming service
10. Clam Chowder from The Clam Bar
Warm up with a steaming bowl of Clam Chowder at The Clam Bar, known for its rich, creamy texture.
- Fresh Ingredients: Made with fresh, locally sourced clams
- Coastal Ambiance: Restaurant's coastal decor and waterfront views add to the dining experience
- Classic Comfort Food: A hearty, comforting dish perfect for cooler weather
11. Fish Tacos from The BoatHouse
Enjoy a twist on traditional tacos with the Fish Tacos at The BoatHouse.
- Seafood Specialty: Known for its exceptional seafood offerings
- Creative Flair: Offers a unique twist on the classic taco
- Waterfront Views: Offers stunning views of the marina and bay
12. Beef Stew from The Speakeasy
Savor a hearty Beef Stew at The Speakeasy, perfect for chilly evenings.
- Comfort Food: A warming and comforting dish for cooler weather
- Locally Sourced Ingredients: Uses locally sourced, high-quality beef
- Hip Atmosphere: Vibrant speakeasy-style decor adds to the dining experience
13. Chicken Parmesan from Vito's Pizzeria
Experience a classic Italian dish with Chicken Parmesan at Vito's Pizzeria.
- Authentic Italian Cuisine: Prepared using traditional Italian methods
- Fresh Ingredients: Made with fresh, high-quality ingredients
- Family-Friendly Atmosphere: A welcoming environment for both families and couples
14. Vegetarian Quiche from Green Thumb Farm
Enjoy a vegetable-packed Vegetarian Quiche at Green Thumb Farm.
- Farm-to-Table: Dishes are prepared using ingredients grown on site
- Seasonal Menu: Menu changes with the availability of seasonal produce
- Rustic Charm: Restaurant's rustic, farmhouse atmosphere adds to the dining experience
15. Greek Salad from The Greek Deli
Freshen up with a classic Greek Salad at The Greek Deli.
- Authentic Greek Cuisine: Prepared using traditional Greek recipes
- Quick Service: Offers quick, convenient service for busy travelers
- Affordable Prices: Provides affordable options for budget-conscious travelers